The Futurist: Technology and Toys — Sometimes Low-Tech is High-Fun
- April 12th, 2007
- 3 Comments

Back when our country was new, kids were given big wooden wheels and rolling sticks and expected to have a good time. More than likely, our little Ezekiels and Wilberforces probably had a ball rolling those wheels down the grassy hills. Of course, it goes without saying that if you gave a Wii-addicted kid such simple pleasures and they’d wonder where the USB hook-up was. Toys have come a long way over the years, and it’s easy to say that kids (and I suppose adults as well) don’t have the time or attention span for simple toys in days when you can get
So what fate lies ahead for the old games that you may (or may not have) grown up with? This week, The Futurist looks at a couple of categories of toys and sees ways modern technology has tried to dip its ugly head, and whether this tech infusion has made the toys more fun, or merely added a few batteries to the boredom.
BOARD GAMES
You may have played Scene It. By adding a flashy DVD to the mix that plays on-screen trivia questions, this board game series tries to ease hyperactive youngsters into the pleasures of board-gaming. Unfortunately, these games absolutely suck. The DVDs are repetitive, unsubstantial, and worst of all — they’re boring. But the problem with Scene It goes beyond crappy content. Rather, the entire concept is flawed. Board games tap into a unique part of our brain. It’s a part that is turns on during power outages, at summer camp, and when it’s really rainy outside. When you play a board game, you joke around, you interact with your fellow players, and you bond. When you throw a trivia DVD on the TV, you turn into a zombie waiting for the questions to pop up. It may be a stretch to say that DVDs are completely incompatible with board games, but I’m going to say that DVDs are completely incompatible with board games.
Interestingly, the best new board game in recent years (if you count the late-90s as recent) is also one that plays like a virtual Greatest Hits of classic board games: Cranium. No DVDs, no annoying sound effects, just trivia, clay, miming, drawing, imitating and humming. The best board games are the ones that require us to delve into the deep recesses of our, well, craniums, and pull up creativity we didn’t know we had. With DVDs and fancy special effect-laden games, this is made more difficult.
Another family favorite: Carcassonne. This mixes Civilization with Sim City with enough strategy and medieval hotness to keep the entire family busy for hours.
REMOTE CONTROL VEHICLES
R/C toys are one area that modern tech has absolutely improved by leaps and bounds. When I was growing up, a decent R/C car cost $300, took several weekends to build, and could easily cause permanent brain damage from sniffing too much model glue. These days, you can get insanely cool cars, planes, and boats for far cheaper — and they are usually ready to rumble right out of the box. Take the Wowee Flytech Dragonfly. Anybody can rip open the box, stuff in some batteries, and get this thing flying almost instantly.
And that’s not to mention the gravity-defying wall-climbing (and likely paint-scuffing) Air Hogs Zero Gravity R/C Wall Crawler. I first saw this thing at the Toy Fair trade show about a year ago, and I was absolutely blown away. Check out the video — when you run this thing into a wall, instead of crashing, it just climbs right up it, Spider-Man-style.
WATER GUNS
One word: Oozinator. We were better off in the days of simple squirt guns, even if they looked real enough to confuse the cops and get a few kids hurt.

Seth Porges writes on future technology and its role in personal electronics for his column, The Futurist. It appears every Thursday and an archive of past columns is available here.









Justine (Who am I?)
1 year ago
I can’t believe you think Scene It sucks and is boring! Who were you playing with?? I play Scene It all the time and always have a blast! And I do “joke around, interact with fellow players, and bond”. It’s hilarious to watch the movie clips and then quote other parts of the film, or remember what you were doing when it came out. And to say DVDs are not compatible with board games is kind of ridiculous, there are hundreds of DVD games at Target or Wal-Mart, but most aren’t as great as Scene It… doesn’t Cranium even have a DVD Game??? Maybe you should try playing Scene It with fun friends next time! If Scene It sucks so bad, why does everyone I know have it??
auto (Who am I?)
1 year ago
R/C vehicles is the best. I like it very much :D
Anon
6 months ago
I’ve played many DVD games, not really through choice. Out of all of them, I’d say Scene-It was actually the best of the lot. It has good questions (I am into films so I should know) and none of them were too easy or difficult for others to understand. Also, the film clips were top quality as well, and the whole thing moved along at a leisurely pace.
Unfortunately, every other DVD game I have played has been absolute rubbish. First, there’s Bullseye. It wants you to press the enter button to throw a dart at the board. Except the position the dart is on-screen doesn’t even correspond with what topic you end up with, so it’s completely pointless as everything is random.
The questions take forever to load, and it’s unbelievably tedious waiting for and sitting through the ’scores’ screen every minute or so.
The Deal or No Deal DVD game could’ve easily been recreated using bits of paper, it’s that simple. It’s just a case of choosing which boxes to open. I’d imagine making the boxes yourself would’ve made the game more interesting ‘cos people would try and swap them with each other and whatever. I was sitting there looking at the screen, trying to feign interest but all the time I just new how basic the coding was for such a game, and how my family would’ve enjoyed a console game much more (but of course they’re totally against such things for no real reason).
Also, the Family Fortunes DVD game was pretty abysmal as well. Another one which wants you to sit around for a week and a half waiting for each screen to load.
The worst part was having to agree with the people I was with when they were praising these DVD games for how ‘clever’ they were. You know, “How does it know our score?!”, “Hasn’t technology come a long way since the brick?!”, etc.
Reply