Dear PR People: All I want for Christmas is no lying

honesty.jpg
It’s nigh on Christmastide and the PR agencies are stirring with red hot news to fill the vacuum between now, Xmas/Kwanzaa/Festivus, CES, and MacWorld. This is a dead period and tech is trying desperately to pull out all its clinkers just to get a little ink before checks and bonuses are cut at the end of the year. I’ve been getting email after email describing red-hot new devices from iPod docks to iPod cases to iPod stickers to things you put on your iPod to make the iPod look bigger, kind of like an iPod banana hammock. Add in the printers, monitors, and janky PCs and you’ve got one full inbox and an angry writer. I can only imagine what the TC crew are getting right now (”Goatcards.org - Greeting Cards Featuring Social Networking Goats!” and “Exclusive: RED HOT SOCIAL NETWORKING PRINTER SYSTEM LETS YOU PRINT WHAT YOUR FRIENDS PRINT” are two possibles), but I’m sure it’s the same. So for Christmas, PR people, here’s what I want.

1. Emails with an image, a spec sheet, and a link. I don’t need you to write a little story at me. If you know me, feel free to be off the cuff. Otherwise, keep it direct and to the point. Want to know what I hate? The press release as it stands. Guess what happens to press releases you send? Garbage. As an aside, take a gander at my inbox. This is a good day and I have 1376 unread messages. I have my Skype and AIM info in my email footers. If you want to contact me, ping me. What you see here is an example of a good, albeit useless, pitch and a bad, bad, bad pitch. I know I’m getting all meta here, dear readers, and you’re seeing how the sausage is made, but understand that as cool as it seems to have Wankertron Inc. emailing you every day, we’re still doing our jobs here and we’re trying to be as efficient as possible.

bad.jpg
This is a BAD email. Notice it is a press release. It sucks and the sender, in turn, sucks.

good2.jpg
Damn, homeslice must have bought an HTML Email for Dummies book, worked with a designer, and took some good, usable pictures. He can have my babies.

2. If you call me and your story lasts longer than 2 minutes, expect to be hung up on. Seriously. Don’t send junior level boiler-room kids to tell me about your great new product, the iPod case with iPod written on it. If it’s important, AIM me.

3. Don’t lie. Send me a spec sheet with all the details. Don’t say it holds 10,000,000 songs if it can hold a 4GB SD card, not included. Don’t say it’s popular with the teens and that the CEO would like to talk to me about teen trends when he’s really just flogging a flower that dances to music.

4. Don’t waste my time. I’ve been trying to take lots of calls with company heads just to see if we can maybe possibly do a podcast series. Instead, I get Joe Wang out in Scranton who knew the guy who designed the carrying case for the product that showed up before the latest one and he basically feeds me canned bullshit for an hour. Make sure your people know what we write about and are ready to talk about real world stuff, like why yours isn’t just another MP3 player. Double this advice in face-to-face meetings. If I have to haul ass to see your head of marketing show me a mocked-up laptop, I’m wasting a few hours of writing time. Tell me what you have, don’t try to surprise me with your hot product, and let me make an educated decision about whether I should take the train into town or ask for a spec sheet and image.

5. Know who we are. It’s 2007, going on 2008. I’ve been blogging for three years and in those three years I’ve seen the medium improve immensely and become an honest and reliable news source on a number of important topics. To hear companies and PR folks tell it, though, blogs are hotbeds of virulent anti-company slander and the print mags with lead times of four months who can offer a one line blurb under a picture of a shiny phone are the real catch. A link on any one of the big two — Giz and Eng — and any number of links from my site and others like it are gold. Do a search for your product. Chances are XXL’s extensive gadget coverage didn’t catch it but JoesiPodCaseBlogforPeopleWhoLikeiPodCases.blogspot.com has it and Giz, me, and everyone else in the free world picked it up. Look at the Technorati 100. Those are your top-tier sites. Then look at the sites those sites link to: PhoneScoop, SlashGear, BGR. All those sites are churning up interest in ways no one thought possible.

One thing NOT to do? Don’t do a Google news search for your topic of interest and send out a blind email. Last week I mentioned on TC that we were doing a Holiday Guide. We hadn’t done one, we were planning it. So I get an email from some choad saying “I read your holiday guide and I think my product, the Choadinator 2000, is a great late addition.” I have to read all your crap, can’t you read mine?

6. Know we have a 10 second lead time. Send out your press releases in a timely manner and bitch to your clients, not us, if someone posts the news before the release. Embargoes do not work anymore and exclusives, as silly as that word is now that every story is taken and run with immediately upon posting, are failing. Exclusives these days are not controlled by you — they come from the wellspring of informants we have in your companies.

7. Hire someone to coddle us and love us and don’t hamstring them. A PR company hired a friend of mine and excellent lead blogger to head up something they were calling “customer relations.” His job was to introduce himself on the Interwebs and answer questions about basic things. Unfortunately, this kid has more connections than all of the flaks he was working with combined and he was soon stepping on toes left and right. He quit because he didn’t like it and they’re out the opportunity of a lifetime. This kid was always available on AIM, he knew the players, and he knew how to filter bullshit. He could be counted on as a trusted source while the PR folks were twiddling their thumbs prepping a red hot press release for distribution at close of business while the news was breaking from here to Taiwan all morning. Hire someone who knows the space and can talk to us like humans. Give them boundaries but don’t force them to kow-tow to old-line PR folks. Let them be a real human voice. Then watch how far and how accurately your message is spread.

Don’t think of this as a rant and please don’t take offense. Think of this as a free $10,000 seminar on talking to bloggers. I know you guys hire consultants to help you “leverage your online experiential marketing” and hit the “low-teen-tween market of web savvy meta-consumers.” These guys won’t be able to help you.

All of us are trying to do our job. Fortunately, my job is more fun than yours: I get to share cool products with cool people. You, on the other hand, have to face down bitchy clients and pushy reporters at the same time. In some ways, maybe your middleman position is becoming extinct and maybe you need to rethink your strategies. Maybe companies should put info releases into their product timelines, bypassing the big PR houses completely. I’d subscribe to an HTC RSS feed if I knew it featured phones, phones, and more phones without all the extraneous noise. Merry Christmas, and to the PR guy who asked me a few months back during a Bulldog Reporter session if I knew that “embargoes are really there to mess with us,” bite me. Hopefully you get a pink slip in your stocking and let others with considerably more savvy take your place.

  • Sphere It

17 Comments so far

 
no image
Doug Haslam (Who am I?)

John– Great post, and no I don’t take ti as a rant. I’m working on training some fellow PR folks in blogger relations (hell– media relations; this is a big trainload of common sense), and I will be using this as an example of free advice not to ignore.

 
no image
Brian (Who am I?)

This is one of the best posts I have read in a long time. Keep up the good work.

 
no image
sdf (Who am I?)

Wow…bitter.

 
no image
Jim (Who am I?)

Wow, what an incredibly small mind you have. But on the off chance that anything you say might actually be right (going with the whole “even blind squirrels find nuts” thing) I for one plan to resign from work today before I get the inevitable pink slip… or worse, you invite me to bite you too.

PS - what the world really needs for Christmas is one more blog

 
no image
John Biggs (Who am I?)

@Jim - Just like it needs one more bad PR person.

 
no image
JP (Who am I?)

JB, you da man. Second the Has-man: awesome post.

 
no image
Had NO Clue (Who am I?)

Fantastic post. Thank you… and for your guide, all I want for Christmas is my 3yr old to stop kicking my subwoofer.

 
no image
MightyMech (Who am I?)

Poor Lou Desidero from Synergy PR got called out for that Kingston release. Hopefully you contacted Lou and talked about the issue before publicly smacking him. You just became Chris Anderson.

 
no image
DJL (Who am I?)

John,

Ironically, the same neat little box you’d like to place PR into begets your entire rant: namely that each writer is different. Similarly, while we’d like every writer to channel Keats in their prose, one cannot expect it. Accept that some people get it, some don’t and move on.

Pigeonholing the PR industry as incompetent or irrelevant serves no real purpose, just as those pigeonhole blogs as “hotbeds of virulent anti-company slander.”

 
no image
John Biggs (Who am I?)

@DJL - You pigeonhole us, we pigeonhole you.
@MightyMech - His was an example of an email I wouldn’t have read if it came from the Pope. I honestly try to be a nice guy and I try to work with PR folks as much as I can. For my trouble I’ve gotten 80% great people I can talk to on a regular basis and 20% of folks who just don’t get it. Today was the day someone had to say what folks were thinking. If I’m the bearer of bad news, too bad for me. Maybe I won’t get that red hot press release tomorrow.

 
no image
pji (Who am I?)

What’s wrong with Puerto Ricans?

 
no image
DJL (Who am I?)

Unfortunately, I am not part of the “you.” I’m not defending PR, nor am I PR practitioner, but merely a marketer (and trained journalist) that understands that some people suck at their craft more than others. That 20% isn’t reading your site or your columns, so why bother?

And regarding being the bearer of bad news, this column has been written multiple times in different forms, lengths and tones. Folks (i.e. writers) have been complaining that people send photos, don’t send photos, cut and paste releases, attach documents, etc., etc., since the email age began. What flies at CrunchGear may not at Engadget or anywhere else. The lesson isn’t that you gave a “a free $10,000 seminar on talking to bloggers,” you just gave a free seminar on how to talk to you. Big difference.

I guess I just don’t see the point.

 
no image
webonics (Who am I?)

That was frickin’ — AWESOME! Merry Christmas, John!!

 
no image
Jay Adair (Who am I?)

Very bold post. I hope you have the backing of your employer :-) Good to see the truth of the matter laid out simply. I hope it benefits you/someone.

 
no image
John Biggs (Who am I?)

I’ve talked with my entire team and a number of bloggers and this advice is almost universal. How about this for a solution? Send out a quick survey to your entire list asking what format they prefer. Andy Rooney will reply that he wants press releases and the rest of the world will probably want what I’m suggesting.

 
no image
Jim (Who am I?)

John, and yet still another clever retort. I am guessing we will not be BFF anytime soon. I have likewise talked to my team and their advice is also almost universal. We’ve been doing media surveys for 20+ years and you would be amazed (well not you, you are too smart to be amazed) at the percentage of on and offline media contacts who spec email “news releases” and “case studies”. As for bloggers, what they want generally depends on their formal training; journalist bloggers like traditional content and non-journalist bloggers want what you want. I have no idea what Andy Rooney wants, but last I heard, even Bill Keller still reads news releases. And by the way, I believe you are thinking of press agents and publicists when you say “PR”… you might want to get up to speed on that.

 
no image
John Biggs (Who am I?)

Jim - I have formal training in journalism and your 20+ years of surveys should have taught you not to respond to fools like me. The flak doth protest too much, methinks.

Trackbacks/Pings

No trackbacks or pings yet.

Leave a Comment

« Back to text comment

Comment template by SezWho

CrunchGear Sponsors