The biggest problem with the Kindle
- January 27th, 2008
- 14 Comments

I was on a flight yesterday with Kindle in hand, hoping to read a little of Dan Brown’s Dress Up an Urban Legend in Faux Scholarship and Sell it to Deracinated People and found the biggest problem with the Kindle: you can’t read it on take-off and landing, at least according to the nice elderly steward on Jetblue. Since your book looks like a computer, you’d best but that stuff away as you make your way into the starry aether because you could interfere with the cockpit’s gyroscopic stabilizer or passenger pigeon homing device. So no matter how much Randall Stross says that the book is going through a “profound modification as it is stripped of its physical shell,” you sure as heck better not whip it out when the seatbelt sign is on, something that amounts to a fatal flaw for the avid reader.










Alex Norman (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Why is this a “problem”, let alone the biggest problem? It can be labeled a little inconvenience at best; but surely not a huge issue.
pidgeon92 (Who am I?)
8 months ago
This is not a problem with the Kindle, but with the airlines. You can say the same thing about laptops, ipods, videogames… anything with a battery in it has to be shut off. I’m sure the avid reader can find some other way to occupy him/herself for ten minutes.
John Biggs (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Just wait until some wily steward tells you you can’t use a “wireless device” on board and tells you to shut off your book.
Craig Newmark (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Yeah, same thing yesterday for me.
Craig
craig@craigslist.org
Amir Segal (Who am I?)
8 months ago
No…this is hardly a problem…. The Kindle’s biggest problem, in *my* opinion is the design of the buttons on the left and right side. No matter how I pick it up, I go to either next or back page. Even in its case/cover, if you push it in to the “grooves” in the case, it goes to next page or activates the back button. The only way to pick and hold it is to hold it in the bottom third of the screen and even then, you press the keys which normally do not cause any page flip but still annoy.
I would be happier with the next and back etc. buttons in the middle of the keyboard where picking it up does not cause a page change which really annoys.
While we’re at it, another issue that I believe will improve, is the Newspaper/Magazine content. I live in Southern Cal, and while several news agencies report on events in the area, there is not even one local newspaper to subscribe to, like the LA Times. This will improve I believe as more content provider create a Kindle version of their content.
thanks for reading.
Peter Ha (Who am I?)
8 months ago
I agree, Amir. The placement of the buttons is my biggest gripe with the Kindle. Otherwise, it’s awesome.
Amir Segal (Who am I?)
8 months ago
yeah, for sure. And since i did not actually say it, but feel it, the Kindle IS awesome and I cannot wait for the improved V2.0 that no doubt will come sometime this year. Maybe color screen…?
Charles Wilkes (Who am I?)
8 months ago
The side switches do not bother me ANYMORE since I fixed the covor. The problem with the cover is that the two retainers built into the cover on the inside at the top and bottom keep the Kindle too far out of the outside edge of the Kindle, while still being totally inadequate in protecting the Kindle from falling out.
What I did was to cut off the two retainers with a sharp razor blade, so it looks like they were never there. Then I took Industrial Strength velcro, and ran a narrow strip up the right side of the Kindle, and at the top and bottom of the left side, leaving the opposing piece still attached to the side now glued to the Kindle. Then I put it into the cover as far to the left as possible, to still allow the cover to close over the Kindle. This leaves an edge of the back case panel exposed, making it easy to pick up the Kindle without touching the next page switch, or the left side switches either. And once it place, press down on it to secure the gummed side of the velcro piece to their proper place on the cover.
I leave both the power and the wireless switch on, and recharge the battery every night next to my bed, as it is the only “book” I have ever found that I can read in bed — it only takes one hand to both hold it and also to do the page turns, for which I use my thumb only. Kindle recommends you recharge frequently, never allowing the battery to become totally discharged. They say it is like the battery in your cell phone, and works best when recharged daily. Actually it will go three days without rescharging if the wireless switch is on, and ten days if it is not.
If I fly, I turn do take it a little bit out of the case just enough to turn the wireless switch off, which is all the aircraft crew has a right to expect. Actually if you left it on but keep it closed it would still violates flight rules, as it is still active until turned off. But once off, the Kindle should be able to be used, as it no longer has wireless access. Unfortunately it may take literally years for all airlines to get the word out to their flight employees.
Charles Wilkes, San Jose, Calif.
Amir Segal (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Sounds interesting that little mod you got going there…I might just give it a shot
Yasser (Who am I?)
8 months ago
I must agree with the rest, this is not a problem. It would be a problem, not a big one, if you couldn’t use it at all on an airplane because of height or some weird stuff.
Hai (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Surely you shouldn’t have it on during takeoff because it’s got EVDO wireless?
John Biggs (Who am I?)
8 months ago
Aha - you can turn EVDO off. It’s this lack of understanding that will make having a kindle a problem.
Constance Reader (Who am I?)
8 months ago
“I’m sure the avid reader can find some other way to occupy him/herself for ten minutes.”
As someone who travels up to 80% of time for business, I must thank you for that great belly-laugh to start off my week. Ten minutes?! Not even out of the smallest podunk airports in the country have I been on a plane went from pushback to 10,000 feet (the altitude at which the announcement is made to turn them on again) in ten minutes. Not in flying around this country, anyway.
drdrew (Who am I?)
8 months ago
No, the biggest problem with the kindle is it makes you look like a tool…