AppleTV missing from WWDC; Are its days numbered, or will there be a glorious future?
- June 13th, 2008
- 9 Comments
Shortly after the launch of the original iPhone a year ago, Steve Jobs held a private conference in Cupertino for the employees of Apple where they learned that anyone working at Apple for more than a year would get a free iPhone. Good for them. He also outlined the approach Apple was taking towards the future, saying that the iPhone makes the fourth leg of a four-legged stool, the other legs being the iPod, Macs, and Apple TV.
At the WWDC keynote on Monday, where Jobs introduced the iPhone 3G, he said something similar, but the stool he spoke of only had three legs: Music (iPod+iTunes), iPhone, and Macs. But where’s Apple TV?
The set-top video box loved by thousands of users wasn’t even mentioned in passing during the keynote. That’s not that surprising considering that developers don’t have access to the box, but the omission from the “stool” analogy is troubling to those of us who use the device. Is Apple dropping the underachieving product, or is it a sleeping giant that could change your living room?
We’d like to see it opened like the iPhone, with its own app store. Not that we’d want it as a computer — though some do — but it’d be great to be able to get a Google Maps or Weather widget for the box. Then as a screen saver for your TV you could get relevant information.
We don’t have that, and there are no rumors of it being in the pipeline. In fact, for the first time since the Apple TV was announced, there really aren’t any rumors about it at all.
But don’t count the box out yet. Because the Apple TV runs OSX, like the iPhone, most apps and games developed for the iPhone will run with little tweaking on the Apple TV. That means it’s entirely possible that we’ll at some point see things for the apps store ported to the device.
Or we might not. Even with the lowered price tag and “Take 2″ software that came out a few months ago the Apple TV is not a stellar seller for Apple. It’s not that the device doesn’t work — indeed, it’s one of my favorite pieces of gear I own, and that’s saying something — it’s that people aren’t really ready for it.
Cable companies have been offering pay-per-view on-demand content for years but the majority of people just don’t use it. There’s a mental hurdle to be overcome and Apple’s just not trying very hard to get over it.
Really, when’s the last time you saw an Apple TV commercial on TV?
But I’m guessing that’s going to change. Come the holiday season, when many games are out for the new iPhone and the fever reaches a peak, why wouldn’t Apple say, “Oh, yah, you can play these games on your home TV now.”
Apple’s already targeting the Nintendo DS with the iPhone and iPod Touch as a gaming platform. Adding the Wii to its sites while staying in the same platform would be a big step, and a welcome one as well. The motion-sensitive game play is great. If you haven’t tried it out yet, find a way. It adds another dimension to the gaming experience you can’t describe.
It wouldn’t be a stretch for Apple to add a wireless controller to the Apple TV that mimicked the iPhone/iPod Touch as a controller, giving the same great way to play to people who can’t go with the iPhone or won’t go to the iPod Touch.
That innovation, coupled with the iTunes music store and the integrated support for all the media on all the computers on the home network would make the Apple TV into the digital hub that Apple wants it to be.
Of course this is speculation. We don’t know what Apple has in store for Apple TV. It’s entirely possible that Jobs has nothing up his sleeves for the device, which would be too bad. But that’s not likely. Jobs has said before that the Apple TV is one of the most exciting devices he’s ever worked on at Apple, and each update it receives gives it more welcome features, like native YouTube support and streaming podcast downloads.
So maybe the Apple TV will turn into an iPhone-like gaming platform. Or maybe Apple will just start promoting it. Or maybe Jobs and company have something planned that we can’t even begin to guess. But one thing’s for sure: Keep an eye on the Apple TV, it will probably surprise you later this year.












Pat Hawks (Who am I?)
2 months ago
To put it bluntly, that sounds like a really dumb idea.
I already have a 360 and a Wii, why do I want my AppleTV to turn into a second rate knock-off?
I *do* agree that there is a lot of potential in that box if they opened it to developers, like your weather widget idea.
What if, while watching a movie on my iPhone, I could click a button and start watching it on AppleTV (like AirTunes for video)?
Overall, though, we only seen the very beginning of video on the internet. AppleTV could be today’s Newton (hopefully not), or Apple could continue to develope new features and promote this thing.
Luck Kanthatham (Who am I?)
2 months ago
Nice speculation, Mike, but I don’t think you will see Apple TV as a gaming platform any time soon; not with the current hardware anyway. It can barely play 720p movies.
However, being a proponent of the Apple TV since its first release and running two Apple TV-related blogs, I do have high hopes for it. The only problem is there is no SDK for it. I’ve been writing about the lack of SDK for the Apple TV numerous times on both my blogs.
I can only hope that you’re right, Matt.
Mike Caprio (Who am I?)
2 months ago
No, the most appropriate thing for Apple to do is cut out the middleman entirely (remove the console) and just build everything into a TV. An “iScreen” HDTV that automatically downloads games/movies/music from iTunes and synchronizes with your portable devices and also gives you a big touchscreen to play with would be the ideal thing. Then it would also integrate with your PS3, Xbox, Wii, and they could even stick in a cablecard slot (not that anyone would use it!)
Elliot Betancourt (Who am I?)
2 months ago
Hi Matt,
A. When the iPhone was introduced Steve said it would be the third leg of his 3 legged stool, and said that the AppleTV was just a “hobby” right now.
B. Actually, I thought we would see some new changes to the AppleTV when Apple launched the new bluetooth keyboard. I couldn’t understand why else they would drop the number pad from the keyboard, unless it was meant to be used in some place where a wider keyboard would be uncomfortable (like the couch). I think that there are alot of possibilities they are playing with at Apple. Just as you imply, how hard would it be to create a an AppStore for the AppleTV? its the one device where Apple has tacitly encouraged hardware hacking.
Pat Hawks (Who am I?)
2 months ago
AppleTV supports Bluetooth?
Apple has encouraged hacking the AppleTV?
Even if there were an AppStore for AppleTV, one would hardly want to just port apps from the iPhone. Not only completely different hardware, but each have totally different interfaces and uses.
Terrence Koonce (Who am I?)
2 months ago
Maybe Apple will integrate “MobileMe” into the AppleTV to allow email and calendar support!
Frank (Who am I?)
2 months ago
Phil mentioned how MobileME (photos) would integrate with AppleTV. That was something I guess.
Michael (Who am I?)
2 months ago
I’ve been saying for a long time that Apple could do a lot with the Apple TV, there is a USB port on it for a reason right? If I was to add anything to it though it might be a ATSC tuner through the USB port that would turn it into a DVR. The only other thing I would suggest Apple do is allow users to plug a Bluetooth dongle into the USB port and then purchase a cheap bluetooth game controller that they could then play games on the Apple TV. Like you said, it runs OS X so it wouldn’t be too much work for devs to port games to it, all they need is Apple’s go ahead and an SDK.
treorblanco (Who am I?)
2 months ago
Why don’t you start a series of what wasn’t mentioned and state it’s demise because of it’s lack of inclusion in WWDC?
iPod was not mentioned.
iPod touch was hardly mentioned at the keynote (sadly and of more concern than anything)
iMac..Uh Oh.. It’s on it’s way out as well.
Where were the new macbooks with the metal exterior?
Clearly it was about the iPhone and it’s software. Apple did not want to dilute the focus with anything else.