European Parliament doesn’t like ‘3 strikes’ anti-piracy schemes
  • 6 Comments
by Nicholas Deleon on March 27, 2009

eu3

Few things are are captivating as the various machinations of European politics, what with the countless measures, motions, proposals and whatnot. The latest one to interest us: the passage of a report that rejects the use of so-called “three strike” anti-piracy schemes, like the one currently being considered by France. The report, which passed the European Parliament (which sounds a lot more important than it really is, if I remember correctly—see the “democracy deficit”), says that while securing the Internet is cool and all, Europe shouldn’t do so at the expense of its citizens’ rights and freedom.

The French law in question—well, proposed law—targets alleged file sharers. Long story short, if The Man catches you trading the latest U2 album or whatever, and catches you doing so three times, you’ll be disconnected from your ISP. If that doesn’t seem insane to you then you’re probably reading the wrong Web site.

Anyway, the moral of the story is that the EU Parliament passed a report saying, yeah, it’s cool and all trying to insure the security of the Internet, but it’s decidedly not cool to do so at the expense of people’s freedoms and rights. Disconnecting alleged file sharers from the Internet, which has become a vital tool in the lives of so many, is an absurd punishment.

Here’s where the democracy deficit comes into play. The French government, currently headed by President Sarkozy, doesn’t necessarily have to take that EP ruling into account; it could well ignore it, and press along with the legislation as it sees fit. (I think; I’m basing that on a class I took in the Fall of 2007.) That’s partly why the EU is so interesting, in a wonkish sort of way: all these different institutions have power, yet at the same the many National Governments still have a degree of autonomy.

Comments rss icon

  • Great news for frenchs ! :)

  • The 3 strike system doesn’t work like you said it does… First you get a warning email, then your ISP cuts off Internet for a week, and lastly you permenantly get your Internet cut.

  • You need to take that class again or might want to read the paper. European law overrules federal law. But this discussion is about finding a European-wide rule, i.e. you also migh want to do the research again for this article too. Don’t get me wrong, your blog is great, this article just lacks the quality of the other topics.

  • Again not a very well thought out piece of potential legleslation as what happens if you have kids downloading and father / mother works from home. Parents know nothing about the downloads……. (do YOU REALLY know what your kids are doing on the internet??) And you are cut off…. need I say more.

Leave Comment

Commenting Options

Enter your personal information to the left, or sign in with your Facebook account by clicking the button below.

Alternatively, you can create an avatar that will appear whenever you leave a comment on a Gravatar-enabled blog.

Trackback URL
bugbug